7 Comments

Hi Don. Just so that I understand when reading your comment here. "When SPY was $415, I sold another 9-day SPY $439 strike put for another $1.08, or a RoR of about 9.6%. The margin of safety was a risky 4%, and the ETF was assigned to me. MOS equals stock price vs strike price."

I never had considered selling a PUT that deep into the money. Am I reading that correctly?

If that PUT gets assigned to you and the price of SPY stays at around $415, you have potentially lost $1,400 minus the premium.

For example, if I sell a PUT today on SPY at the current mark of $437, then if I move into the money to $460, for March 28th. And if SPY stays at $437 or lower, the up front premium on that trade is $2134, but my potential loss is $2,400 or greater, minus the premium I earned up front.

Why would I want to design this trade so that it almost guarantees that I get assigned that stock at such a high cost? Even though the premium is healthy?

Am I looking at this, your trade correctly?

Expand full comment
author

Patrick. Good catch. Unfortunately, I didn't see the error until about an hour after I sent the newsletter to subscribers. The stock price was about $457 when I did the trade. I've corrected the number, but the platform won't let me send the post again.

Expand full comment
Mar 18, 2022Liked by Donald E. L. Johnson

Did you consider today's ex-date for SPY?

Expand full comment
author
Mar 18, 2022·edited Mar 18, 2022Author

SPY is ex dividend today. My 3.18.22 $440 strike is safe because pre market SPY is at about $437, down from last night's $439.70 close. Are you saying I should not buy it back today when and if the option falls to $0.05 or lower? I'm sure I can buy the option back for less than the dividend. Is that what you would do?

In any case, I don't think I'll roll the trade or any trades until Monday. Nobody knows what Putin will do over the weekend.

Expand full comment
Mar 18, 2022Liked by Donald E. L. Johnson

Since SPY $440s now in-the-money, if you are trading in a tax-free account (like an IRA), I would suggest letting it be assigned today, thus capturing both the ex-dividend and all the time value from when you initiated the position.

Expand full comment
author

With SPY at $444, it would have cost me $4 or $5 to buy the calls back. Since the dividend was about $1.64, it didn't make sense to do that. So I let it be called in a taxable account because of the low dividend yield. But because I get good RoR from selling puts and calls, it could be in an IRA with high dividend paying stocks.

Expand full comment

Good point. I missed that when looking at this.

Expand full comment